Booth Gardner, former governor of Washington state, has a new campaign: “death with dignity.” Largely because of his own struggle with Parkinson’s disease, Gardner advocates the legalization of assisted suicide for the terminally ill. His logic, according to an article in the New York Times Magazine: “My life, my death, my control.”
Gardner hopes to put an assisted suicide bill on the November 2008 ballot. He needs 225,000 signatures for this to happen, which shouldn’t be difficult when the campaign gets funds from Gardner’s own large fortune and other right-to-die groups.
A similar bill but failed in 1991 after a series of television advertisements helped generate public opposition. Gardner hopes this particular law will be a starting place. Since Parkinson’s is not terminal, this law would not affect him or others with disabilities. He believes they should have the same option.
Both secular and religious groups oppose the bill. Wesley J. Smith, senior fellow of the Discovery Institute and an attorney for the International Task Force on Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide, said the practice is anti-liberal as much as it is anti-religious. Susan Wolf, for instance, told New York Times Magazine that women are especially vulnerable to the view that their lives are no longer valuable. A disproportionate number of women sought Jack Kevorkian’s help to commit suicide. State Senator Margarita Prentice worries that the law will pressure minorities and promote the unequal medical treatment of Latinos.
Smith also discussed the faith-based argument: “All life is a gift from God and engaging in assisted suicide interferes with their obligation to care for the vulnerable and the weak.”
A broad-based coalition must oppose the bill for it to fail, Smith said. This kind of coalition has successfully blocked similar bills in the UK, California and Hawaii. The only state to currently allow the practice is Oregon.